Britains worst bathing site: is treated sewage to blame?

Britains worst bathing site: is treated sewage to blame?

A sign at French Weir Park alongside the River Tone in Taunton clearly advises against swimming. Despite this caution, a group of four women—Jo, Jenny, Sue, and another Jo—regularly enjoy swimming together in the river. Jenny Hillier describes their experience positively, saying, “People think, oh you’re swimming down by the supermarket, that can’t be very nice, but it’s gorgeous,” as they gather after a refreshing October swim with coats and hot drinks to warm up.

Swimming in this part of the River Tone has a history dating back over a century. Only recently, in 2024, has French Weir Park been officially recognized as a bathing site, resulting in water quality monitoring by the Environment Agency (EA) from May through September. This testing often confirms what the women have sensed themselves—that the water quality is frequently poor. Jo Macdonald notes, “There are times when we’ve come down and we haven’t got in, either because of the look or the smell. We don’t take risks. We don’t put our faces in. We don’t swim with cuts or anything.” Jenny also shares her experience of illness after swimming, having suffered from diarrhoea, vomiting, and muscle cramps shortly after one swim. She reflects, “I’d swum and then within six hours I was unwell. I was poorly for probably about seven to 10 days and it was not nice. I think it was the river that day.” Despite this, Jenny continues swimming, rationalizing that “There are germs everywhere, all over the place. You can catch Covid in Tesco.”

Investigations into the river’s water quality were furthered by Dr. Rob Morley from Index Microbiology. While examining samples near his Bristol laboratory, Morley highlighted bacterial contamination levels around treated wastewater discharge points. He pointed out that water samples taken just above the treated wastewater outlet showed 199 CFU (colony-forming units) of E. coli per 100 milliliters—a figure considered safe for swimming. However, just below the discharge point, the E. coli count surged to 7,701 CFU, a reading more than eight times above regulatory limits. Morley commented, “You can see where it’s seeding the river with pollution.” He also noted that downstream dilution would typically reduce bacterial counts but emphasized the clear impact treated effluent has on this stretch of the River Tone. Alongside these findings, Dr. Andrew Thompson from the Institute of Chemical Engineers referenced a 2024 report warning that elevated concentrations of bacteria and viruses are common during the summer months when river flows are lower, posing serious health risks if ingested. Thompson told the BBC that although the E. coli levels discovered were not illegal or particularly unusual, this stems from a lack of specific regulations governing bacterial limits in treated effluent discharged by water companies.

To better understand the origin of the bacteria, further analysis was conducted with help from University of Bristol researchers. Dr. Morley carried out e-DNA testing on E. coli samples from the bathing site to determine whether contamination was likely of human or animal origin. The results were mixed, indicating a complex microbial community where some bacteria could be traced back to humans, others to animals, and some were simply environmental types. Morley explained, “Some were from humans, some were from animals and some were just generic from the environment. It definitely suggests that some of the E. coli is definitely coming from human origins, therefore potentially from that treatment works.” Both the Environment Agency and Wessex Water are actively investigating the persistent poor water quality in Taunton, with treated effluent discharge remaining a high suspect. Wessex Water stated that their Bradford on Tone treatment works was operating normally within its permit limits.

Jim Flory, the EA’s regional manager for the south-west, remarked on the regulatory situation surrounding bathing waters, explaining that permits for sewage treatment works are designed mainly to protect river ecology and wildlife, not necessarily human swimmers. He stated, “They’ve not set permits for bathing water regulations, which are all about protecting people who may want to be swimming, canoeing or using the water.” This regulatory gap often results in a cycle where once a site is officially designated as a bathing area and periodic testing reveals elevated bacterial levels, authorities must undertake a lengthy process to identify contamination sources and evaluate the financial feasibility of remediation efforts

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More