Government backs welfare shake-up to prevent ‘lost generation’

Government backs welfare shake-up to prevent ‘lost generation’

The government has expressed support for extensive reforms aimed at preventing a generation of young people from becoming trapped on benefits, based on recommendations from former minister Alan Milburn. His plan calls for significant investment in personalized assistance for under-25s who are not in employment, education, or training (Neets), with funding partly sourced through reductions in certain welfare benefits.

Milburn’s proposal includes tax incentives for businesses and major changes in education, projecting that by 2036, around 440,000 young people will secure employment. Prime Minister Andy Burnham endorsed the fundamental ideas of Milburn’s review, expressing confidence that he can rally Labour MPs to pass laws implementing the proposed changes. Burnham plans to present a detailed government response the following month, following the submission of a separate report on Personal Independence Payments (PIPs) by Social Security Minister Sir Stephen Timms.

Burnham emphasized the unprecedented, comprehensive approach of the Milburn plan, stating: “I have never in my years in politics seen a wholesale, whole government approach to supporting the next generation.” He added that the vision behind these reforms would gain widespread support because allowing a generation to grow up without hope would be detrimental to Britain’s future. To oversee the rollout of these recommendations, the government has appointed Milburn as the head of a newly established Youth Opportunities Unit.

While Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch acknowledged agreement with Milburn’s assessment of the issues facing young people, she criticized Labour for worsening the situation by raising employers’ National Insurance rates and the youth minimum wage. Burnham appears unlikely to encounter opposition from his MPs on a scale similar to the resistance that blocked former Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer’s plans for £5bn in welfare cuts last year. However, some left-leaning Labour members and the Unison union have expressed concern that cutting health-related benefits could push vulnerable young people into poverty.

The Work and Pensions Secretary, Pat McFadden, highlighted the need for the welfare system to be assessed based on individuals’ life stories and potential, rather than just monthly income snapshots. Speaking in the Commons alongside Burnham and Chancellor John Healey, McFadden rejected stereotypes of young people as “snowflakes and shirkers.” He stressed that the one million young people not engaged in work or training had been denied “the prospect of a good future,” a challenge demanding far more than a standard government response. McFadden announced plans to publish initial welfare reform proposals early next year, with legislation to follow.

Milburn’s comprehensive 250-page report recommends an overhaul of the benefits system for under-25s. Notably, it suggests ending the health-related top-ups of Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payments, replacing them with a new “youth allowance” aligned with the basic Universal Credit rate, with higher payments for those living independently. The report advocates for reduced National Insurance contributions for employers hiring 21- to 24-year-olds, especially within retail and hospitality, making it more cost-effective to employ younger workers. It also calls for a substantial increase in post-18 college places, a legal right to work, education, or training, and the creation of a Youth Opportunity Service that pairs young people with a dedicated advisor and personalized plan. Schools would be required to identify and assist pupils at risk of becoming Neet, while also ensuring work experience opportunities are provided.

The report estimates that around £5.8 billion will be needed by 2036-37 for enhanced mental health and employment support. Milburn urges the government to begin implementing reforms next year with an initial £500 million, reallocated from existing budgets. Though the plan is not designed as a cost-saving measure—the government anticipates net financial benefits only from 2036/37 onward—it aims to significantly reduce the percentage of young people aged 16-24 who are Neet, from one of the highest rates in Europe at 13% down to 5%, the UK’s lowest recorded figure.

At the launch, Milburn insisted that half-hearted efforts would not suffice, noting, “Britain is at risk of losing a generation of young people, not because they lack talent, not because they lack ambition, not because they do not want to work. This is not a crisis of aspiration; it is a crisis of opportunity.”

The report leaves an open question regarding the devolved nations of Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, as it does not provide detailed recommendations for those areas where education, skills, health, and local government are managed independently. Milburn suggested that the UK government and devolved administrations should establish shared definitions, common outcome measures, and regular reviews of progress. Scotland’s Education Secretary Màiri McAllan welcomed potential collaboration but pointed out that many of the vocational and training reforms suggested for England already exist in Scotland. Meanwhile, the Welsh government expressed readiness to work with the UK government to maximize benefits for Welsh youth.

Reaction from political figures has varied. Reform UK leader Nigel Farage agreed broadly with Milburn’s analysis but criticized the pace and scale of the proposals, calling them “too little and too slow.” The Lib Dem treasury spokesperson Daisy Cooper argued the government should support high street employers who often provide young people with their first job, eliminate what she terms an “unfair jobs tax,” and seek a new economic and defence partnership with the EU. On the other hand, Green Party leader Zack Polanski described the proposals as a “flimsy sticking plaster,” accusing them of intending to cut support for disabled young people while subsidizing companies to hire cheap labour

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More