Drumcree: High Court quashes decision to restrict annual Orange Order parade

Drumcree: High Court quashes decision to restrict annual Orange Order parade

The High Court recently overturned a ruling made by the Parades Commission that placed restrictions on the annual Orange Order parade at Drumcree in Portadown. This judgment came after a legal challenge initiated by a member of the Orange Order. The Parades Commission had consistently barred the parade, held each July, from proceeding along Garvaghy Road, a predominantly nationalist area—a stance it has maintained since 1998.

The original ban dates back to 1998 when the Parades Commission denied the Orange Order permission to march down Garvaghy Road, sparking significant unrest in Portadown and across Northern Ireland. This decision followed years of increasing tension over the parade route, which had been a traditional part of the Order’s annual march on the Sunday before the 12th of July. While the march had occasionally been restricted by the Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC) in earlier years, including notably in 1996, attempts to allow the parade often led to violent clashes. The situation in Drumcree and related disputes prompted the establishment of the independent Parades Commission to seek peaceful resolutions to these contentious parades.

The latest court decision may open the door for future applications to permit the parade along Garvaghy Road, though any such event would require a new, formal application and subsequent decision. The challenge against the commission’s ruling argued that the restrictions were imposed without sufficient evidence of potential disorder and that the commission had improperly made dialogue with Garvaghy Road residents a condition for the parade. Additionally, it was contended that the Parades Commission did not consider submissions from relevant political representatives, including Carla Lockhart, the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) Member of Parliament for the area. The commission conceded the case before a full hearing, requesting the court to nullify its decision.

The 1998 decision led to a heavy security presence, with around 1,000 police officers and as many soldiers deployed to enforce the ban. Following the ruling, thousands of Orange Order members rallied in Portadown demanding access to the road, resulting in widespread disorder and over 2,500 public order incidents recorded by the RUC over the days surrounding the parade. Attacks on security forces numbered over 600 and involved shootings and bombings. The violence also caused significant property damage and resulted in the tragic deaths of three children in an arson attack, drawing international attention and condemnation. Since then, the Portadown District Lodge has sought to hold the parade annually (with exceptions such as during the COVID-19 pandemic), but the Parades Commission has consistently refused permission, limiting marchers to proceed only as far as a police cordon before turning back

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More