Auto Amazon Links: No products found. Blocked by captcha.
Richard Fisher is an avid beer enthusiast who enjoys brewing his own ale at home and once contemplated purchasing a brewery. He never anticipated that investing £12,000 in Brewdog, a rapidly growing beer company, might lead to significant financial losses. As a former small business adviser from Suffolk, Richard found the prospect of owning a stake in the innovative Scottish brewery attractive. He described the brand as “maverick, independent, to a certain extent rebellious,” qualities he admired when deciding to invest.
Brewdog was founded in 2007 by James Watt and Martin Dickie, two young entrepreneurs frustrated with the traditional UK beer market. Starting in a small industrial unit in Fraserburgh, Aberdeenshire, they launched a craft beer business positioning themselves as disruptors of a perceived “stuffy” industry. Two years after their launch, Brewdog initiated their well-known “Equity for Punks” fundraising campaign, which invited the public to buy shares in the business. The scheme offered investors incentives such as discounts on beer, free birthday drinks, and exclusive invites to lively annual general meetings featuring live music and tastings. This approach proved hugely popular, with over 200,000 investors putting money into the company before the scheme closed to new participants in 2021.
The Equity for Punks initiative helped Brewdog raise approximately £75 million, fueling its growth into a global brand with four breweries and more than 100 bars worldwide. While many small investors imagined their shares could become highly valuable, allowing for liquidity through stock market trading, the reality became more complicated. In 2017, US equity firm TSG Consumer Partners acquired a 22% stake in Brewdog, but unlike Equity for Punks shareholders, they were granted “preference shares.” This meant that in the event of a company sale, TSG would have priority in recouping their investment plus any owed interest, potentially leaving little for ordinary shareholders like Richard.
The disparity between institutional and small investor arrangements created frustration and uncertainty among Equity for Punks participants. Richard, who bought shares around five or six years ago, said he was unaware of the preferential terms granted to TSG until discussions surfaced on an online forum. Trading days that allowed shareholders to buy and sell shares have not been held since 2022, leading Richard to state, “My shares have effectively been worthless for the last two or three years.” Other investors, like Chris Huish from South Wales, who bought £500 worth of shares, valued the discounts and community but admitted, “There’s not much transparency on that. I don’t think I’m going to get it back.”
Despite these issues, Brewdog has not been accused of any illegality. Investors were advised to read risk disclosures and terms carefully before joining Equity for Punks. Gareth Fitzgerald, who invested £1,000, acknowledged the risks inherent in such ventures but expressed disillusionment over Brewdog’s handling of institutional investment and its effects on smaller shareholders. He remarked, “You know when you invest in shares their value can go up or down… But that’s probably where I fell foul because you assume there is going to be some proper resale value at some point for your shares.” He added that many investors now feel their funds were used primarily to support the business with no straightforward exit opportunity.
Brewdog has declined to provide detailed comments about the concerns raised by small investors. However, in a statement posted on an Equity for Punks online forum, current CEO James Taylor confirmed that the consultancy firm Alix Partners is assisting with exploring “strategic options” and “investment opportunities.” He reassured the community, saying, “It remains business as usual across our bars, venues and breweries. We remain fully committed to our customers, our crew, our partners – and to you, our Equity Punk community. Your continued support is a fundamental part of Brewdog’s journey, and we will keep you updated as the process progresses.
Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More
Auto Amazon Links: No products found. Blocked by captcha.