Why peril could lie in the Welsh valleys for Starmer

Why peril could lie in the Welsh valleys for Starmer

In just over 100 days, Welsh voters will head to the polls to choose their new devolved government. Current opinion polls indicate a potentially historic shift, with Labour facing the possibility of being rejected for the first time ever in Wales. This is particularly striking given the region’s deep-rooted connection to Labour, where figures like Keir Hardie, Aneurin Bevan, Neil Kinnock, and Michael Foot have left significant legacies. Despite this history, the atmosphere within Welsh Labour is reportedly grim as the party prepares for the upcoming elections.

These elections will determine leadership over crucial public services such as health, education, transport, and planning, which directly impact daily life in Wales. Beyond their local importance, the results carry wider implications for the UK Labour Party, especially in terms of the political standing of leader Sir Keir Starmer. Labour losing Wales would constitute a serious psychological blow to the party, marking a loss of one of its last resilient strongholds after setbacks in Scotland and parts of England in recent years.

According to Dr. Jac Larner from Cardiff University, Labour has historically dominated Welsh politics since devolution began in 1999 and has maintained control in general elections for over a century. However, this time there is a real possibility that Labour may not only fail to be the largest party but could even fall behind other parties. Laura McAllister, a public policy professor at the Wales Governance Centre, emphasizes the rapid nature of Labour’s decline, which has taken many by surprise, including members of the party itself. The fact that Labour currently governs both in Cardiff and at Westminster adds to voters’ impatience, potentially doubling the blame directed at the party.

Meanwhile, the electoral contest has become unusually competitive, with Welsh nationalists Plaid Cymru and Reform UK emerging as leading contenders. Larner explains that long-term governance inevitably results in voter fatigue, creating opportunities for other parties to challenge Labour’s dominance. Plaid Cymru, in particular, appears poised to become the largest party for the first time, buoyed by increasing numbers of people identifying solely as Welsh. McAllister, who has a long association with Plaid Cymru, notes that while the permanence of this political shift is uncertain, Plaid is successfully positioning itself as the best party to represent Welsh interests. Reform UK, unburdened by the historical associations faced by the Conservatives, is also gaining traction as a viable right-wing alternative in the region, according to Larner.

As the election approaches, it seems the traditional heavyweight parties of Westminster, Labour and the Conservatives, are losing their grip on Welsh politics. Senior Labour figures privately point to their extensive governing experience, which their rivals lack, but the electorate appears drawn more to new political forces and fresh ideas. This shift poses a significant challenge to Labour’s position in the very heartland of its founding figure, Keir Hardie, and casts questions over the future leadership of Sir Keir Starmer amid the prospect of electoral defeat

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More