Accounting errors and 'incompetence' led to Coventry's City of Culture charity collapse

Accounting errors and 'incompetence' led to Coventry's City of Culture charity  collapse

A BBC investigation has uncovered that a series of significant accounting errors heavily contributed to the downfall of the Coventry City of Culture Trust. Internal meetings characterized these errors as a result of “incompetence,” which ultimately left the trust with a £1 million deficit. This financial shortfall precipitated a crisis that led to the charity entering administration in 2023, shortly after it secured a £1 million loan from the city council intended to cover temporary funding gaps.

At the time, the trust’s leadership publicly framed the loan as a short-term necessity. However, confidential documents obtained by the BBC reveal admissions that the problems stemmed from “human error” and a “failure of governance.” Former CEO Martin Sutherland expressed regret over the mistakes while also highlighting external pressures contributing to the trust’s financial collapse. Sutherland emailed the BBC stating, “It was hard to read that the demise of the trust continues to make an impact on individuals and organisations in Coventry and beyond.” The trust never repaid the loan and left behind £4.2 million in unpaid debts, affecting various local organizations including cultural venues and Coventry University.

The fallout included job losses for dozens of employees and the cancellation of a two-year cultural enhancement program aimed at boosting the city’s arts scene. Minutes from the trust’s executive board meetings, released following a Freedom of Information request — after Coventry City Council initially refused access and the Information Commissioner intervened — exposed internal concerns about the financial problems. While there were suspicions of potential fraud, trustees were repeatedly reassured that no criminal activity was involved. One insider indicated that spending continued despite unawareness of the underlying accounting mistakes. Another remarked, “I don’t think at any stage anyone was operating in any way that was Machiavellian or trying to cook the books. I think it was pure financial incompetence, which is breathtaking.”

Since 2023, the Charity Commission has been investigating the trust’s collapse. While a compliance case is active, no formal statutory inquiry—with powers to compel information or disqualify trustees—has been launched, despite growing calls for such action to clarify accountability. Councillor Gary Ridley, Conservative leader in Coventry, described the revelations as “truly shocking,” adding, “It tells a tale of incompetence. It tells a tale of chaos.” The trust had originally been established in 2015 to manage Coventry’s successful bid to be UK City of Culture in 2021, a designation that brought significant investment and highlighted the city’s vibrant music, dance, and arts scene. Despite pandemic-related delays and revenue shortfalls, the trust initially reported no major financial concerns in mid-2022, but serious issues quickly emerged soon after

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More