Publisher apologises for 'the hurt' it caused Kate Clanchy over controversy

Publisher apologises for 'the hurt' it caused Kate Clanchy over controversy

A global publisher has issued an apology to acclaimed author Kate Clanchy following a literary controversy that unfolded four years ago. Clanchy found herself embroiled in a heated online dispute in 2021, where she was accused of employing racist language to describe children in her book titled Some Kids I Taught and What They Taught Me. Pan Macmillan, the publisher, has now expressed regret to Clanchy and others involved in the dispute, acknowledging the unfortunate nature of the events that transpired.

In her award-winning book, Clanchy delves into her experiences of teaching English and poetry in British state schools over a period of 30 years. Despite receiving the prestigious Orwell Prize for Political Writing in 2020, the book later came under intense scrutiny in an online storm that erupted a year after the accolade. Critics accused Clanchy of racism, classism, and ableism, citing concerns about the language used in the book and its alleged focus on physical characteristics of children.

Following the controversy, Clanchy severed ties with Pan Macmillan’s Picador imprint, her publisher for more than two decades. She expressed feeling unsupported throughout the ordeal and revealed the impact it had on her mental health, disclosing thoughts of suicide. The fallout from the events also affected those who criticized the book, with some facing backlash and vilification for their efforts to challenge what they considered dehumanizing and stereotypical depictions in Clanchy’s work.

An internal exploration of communications within Picador during the contentious period sheds light on the publisher’s internal deliberations on whether to stand by the author or address the online backlash. Despite an initial draft of a press release emphasizing Clanchy’s positive contributions and character, the final statement issued publicly apologized for any harm caused and the emotional distress experienced by readers engaging with the text. The aftermath of the controversy continues to reverberate, prompting reflection on broader themes such as navigating societal differences, representation of diverse voices in literature, and the evolving dynamics of public discourse in the digital age

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More