Opponents of the new regulations mandating individuals to obtain planning permission for second homes have been informed that they have the option to pursue their case through a judicial review process. Cyngor Gwynedd was the pioneering local authority to implement the directive, known as an Article 4 Direction, which was sanctioned by the Welsh government in October 2022. A High Court judge has decreed that a hearing should be held to evaluate a grievance made by a complainant asserting that the council misconstrued the alterations to the planning system and neglected to consider the potential impact on new holiday homes. The primary objective behind the council’s implementation of this measure was to address a substantial housing crisis; nonetheless, opponents argue that it will adversely affect property prices, tourism, and the overall economy.
In his ruling, Mr. Justice Pepperall approved the complainant’s request to seek a judicial review on one specific claim but dismissed it on four other grounds. A judicial review entails a High Court proceeding in which a judge is tasked with determining whether a minister, official, or public entity violated the law in their decision-making process. A representative for Cyngor Gwynedd stated that the introduction of the Article 4 regulation was aimed at managing the utilization of residences as second homes and holiday accommodations in its jurisdiction. They mentioned, “We will assess this development and our next course of action, while acknowledging that the judge’s ruling permits a hearing on a singular basis, and is not a definitive verdict.” Last month, the Eryri National Park Authority initiated a similar rule, becoming the initial park to do so, contending that half of Eryri’s population — also recognized as Snowdonia — have been priced out of the housing sector. Although some residents of Eryri have endorsed this step as a means of restricting the number of second homes and holiday lodgings, critics have highlighted that local enterprises are already facing hardships and that it could create an unwelcoming environment for visitors
Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More
