Staff gagging clauses lifted ahead of probe into culture at data watchdog

Staff gagging clauses lifted ahead of probe into culture at data watchdog

The UK government has confirmed that non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) signed by employees of the country’s information regulator will be lifted, enabling staff to discuss the workplace culture openly. An independent review into the working environment at the Information Commission is expected to be outlined soon, with full details set to be published next week. This move comes in the wake of the watchdog’s chief resigning five months ago amid allegations of sexually inappropriate conduct.

A government spokesperson clarified that the Information Commission will not enforce any “gagging clauses” to hinder staff participation in the review, stating, “The regulator will not use the terms of any agreement to prevent people from participating in the review.” Additional information regarding the scope of the investigation and the appointment of an independent reviewer will be shared shortly. The Information Commission, noted for its high-profile role overseeing AI regulation, data protection, and Freedom of Information requests, has found itself under scrutiny following recent internal issues.

The organization has been without a permanent leader since John Edwards resigned earlier this year, following an independent probe that identified a “case to answer” related to reports of inappropriate behavior towards employees, including sexual harassment. The investigation concluded that Edwards’ conduct “fell short of the conduct expected from a public official.” In his resignation statement on LinkedIn, Edwards contested the investigation process but acknowledged the unfeasibility of remaining in his position. He admitted, “I have accepted that there have been occasions where I exercised poor judgement and made attempts at humour that were inappropriate and caused offence.”

Throughout Edwards’ tenure, Freedom of Information disclosures revealed that 16 current and former staff members were bound by confidentiality clauses costing over £354,000, with nine agreements containing “non-derogatory clauses” that legally barred them from public criticism. Although these restrictions only affected a small portion of the over 1,000 employees, official guidance advises public bodies to use such clauses sparingly and not to discourage staff from raising concerns. Since 2025, new legislation prohibits the use of NDAs to silence employees facing harassment or abuse.

Following Edwards’ departure, the government announced a review into the Commission’s culture and governance, prompted by the independent investigator’s findings of sexual harassment and bullying, which horrified officials. However, despite being announced five months ago, the investigation has yet to be initiated. Recently, civil service unions PCS and FDA have urged for a thorough external review into the circumstances that led to Edwards’ resignation. They also called for the release of staff from NDAs to enable full cooperation with the review.

Concerns regarding workplace culture extend beyond the former commissioner, with internal surveys indicating that 14% of employees have experienced bullying, harassment, or discrimination. Both current and former staff have reported witnessing or enduring similar issues. PCS General Secretary Fran Heathcote criticized the enduring toxic leadership environment, stating, “Our members… have been failed for too long by a toxic leadership culture that has allowed bullying and harassment to persist, leaving many staff fearful of speaking out.” Though Heathcote acknowledged recent positive communication with the Commission and the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS), she emphasized the need for the review to be “genuinely independent, robust in its approach, and prepared to identify where accountability lies.”

Caroline Dinenage, chair of the DCMS select committee, stressed the urgent need for strong leadership at the Information Commission, asserting that following Edwards’ exit, a leadership void has worsened pre-existing issues. She urged the government to appoint someone committed to transforming the organizational culture and safeguarding staff, calling it “vital” that a new leader can “set a new tone and is dedicated to changing attitudes and protecting staff.” An Information Commission spokesperson highlighted the organization’s commitment to the independent review and noted that a new Board, appointed in the summer, is working hard to implement fresh leadership, new governance structures, and a revised strategy. They expressed dedication to listening to the review’s findings and further improving the workplace culture

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More