Police officers lied about searches connected to fatal St Mellons crash, hearing told

Police officers lied about searches connected to fatal St Mellons crash, hearing told

A police misconduct hearing has revealed that two officers reportedly fabricated claims of searching the homes of two young women linked to a fatal crash. PCs Richard Hardwick and Lauren Livingstone are accused of gross misconduct for allegedly providing false information regarding their missing person inquiries before a car crash was discovered in woodland near St Mellons, Cardiff, in 2023.

At a hearing in Newport, the officers stand accused of dishonesty in official records and when reporting to a senior officer. They asserted that searches had been conducted at the residences of Eve Smith, who died in the crash, and Sophie Russon, but these claims are contested. Both officers appeared at the hearing and denied the allegations against them.

The incident involves three young women—Smith, Darcy Ross, and Russon—who were longtime friends. They spent the evening of 2 March 2023 together in Newport, where they met three men: Rafel Jeanne, Shane Loughlin, and Joel Lia. The six then traveled to a caravan in Trecco Bay, Porthcawl, for a party before leaving in the early hours. Shortly after dropping off a passenger in Cardiff, the car carrying the group left the road and crashed.

By the evening of 3 March, concerned family members reported the women missing after failing to contact them and noticing the absence of social media activity. Claire Ross and Nathan Russon, mothers of two of the missing women, reported their children to Newport police. During this time, Eve Smith’s mother discovered her daughter’s handbag at the caravan but found no sign of the group. The individuals at the caravan were described as unhelpful, raising her suspicion that something was wrong. Smith’s sister later also reported her missing, providing sensitive information to the police, compounding concerns about the situation. Additional undisclosed concerning information relating to the men involved was added to police records.

PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone were working a 16:00 to 03:00 shift and assigned the task of visiting the two homes to gather details and conduct searches—a standard procedure in missing persons investigations designed to confirm whether the individuals were present or had left hints such as notes or belongings. However, although each officer was assigned a specific residence—Livingstone to Smith’s and Hardwick to Russon’s—they visited both addresses together and submitted paperwork afterward. PC Livingstone stated she spoke with Smith’s brother and mother, recording in logs that nothing appeared amiss. This log entry was later deemed dishonest and misleading by the hearing panel.

PC Hardwick wrote in the logs for Russon’s property that a “Premise search conducted,” a statement the panel described as straightforward evidence of dishonesty. Family statements contradicted this, with Russon’s father saying he never permitted any search of his daughter’s bedroom. The panel was urged to assess the credibility of families’ accounts, and there was no cause to doubt their testimony. Both officers reportedly informed Sgt Cheverton, who was overseeing the investigation, that searches had been completed, but the panel acknowledged that while these falsehoods might not have affected the tragic outcome, the officers were nevertheless expected to perform their duties properly. This failure was labeled serious.

A separate team of officers was assigned to search Ross’s home, and there was an agreement that some form of search took place there. By August 2023, the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) began reviewing Gwent Police’s handling of the missing persons case. PC Hardwick denied the allegations in his statement, asserting he had searched Russon’s bedroom. PC Livingstone also participated in an interview with the IOPC, stating she had not intentionally been untruthful but admitted she could not clearly recall due to elapsed time. Should the officers be found guilty of gross misconduct, they face immediate dismissal without notice. The hearing is scheduled to continue until the end of the week

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More