Carnaby Street lights filmed by sea of phones prompts backlash

Carnaby Street lights filmed by sea of phones prompts backlash

A recent video showing the Christmas lights switch-on event on Carnaby Street has sparked a significant reaction online, not because of the festive display itself, but due to the overwhelming number of people recording the spectacle on their phones. When BBC London shared the footage, many viewers took to the comments to express their disappointment at the sight of countless screens raised instead of people watching the event directly. One commenter nostalgically remarked, “Remember when we used to look at stuff directly with our eyes? Those were the good old days,” while others described the scene as “sad” and “depressing.”

Natalie Cassidy, known for her role in EastEnders, also weighed in, highlighting the emotional impact of the mass phone usage rather than direct observation. She stated, “Why is this piece not mentioning the fact that no-one is looking through their eyes at this beautiful display? It’s really scary and depressing.” Some commenters even questioned the value of filming moments like these if people are not fully present, with one stating that most people would likely never watch their recorded videos again, implying that such behavior detracts from truly living in the moment.

Research supports the idea that relying on phone cameras during events can impair memory. Since the widespread adoption of camera phones, studies have suggested that capturing photos or videos may interfere with the brain’s ability to remember experiences accurately. This phenomenon, known as “photo-taking-impairment,” was first identified by cognitive psychologist Dr. Linda Henkel in 2014. Follow-up research has shown that people often depend on their devices to remember, rather than actively committing moments to memory through their own senses.

Dr. Kaitlyn Regehr, an academic specializing in smartphone culture from University College London and the University of Toronto, pointed out that while mass phone filming is not new, the strong online backlash this year is noteworthy. She explained, “What’s significant is that this year there’s a lot of critical public discourse happening. And that, I think, is really, really positive.” According to Dr. Regehr, these reactions reflect societal unease over the increasing influence of technology and big tech companies on daily life. Factors such as upcoming social media restrictions for under-16s in the UK and legal actions against social media firms in the US are contributing to a growing public desire for greater control over technology use. She also suggested that the timing of the backlash around Christmas – a time many remember before smartphones were prevalent – might intensify people’s feelings about experiencing the holiday season unmediated by screens, particularly for parents concerned about their children’s interactions with technology

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More