Disabled St Helens man spied upon by bosses wins £300k payout

Disabled St Helens man spied upon by bosses wins £300k payout

Alan Jones, a 59-year-old man with a longstanding history in the glass-making industry, was wrongly dismissed from his role at Pilkington UK Ltd after being covertly monitored by his employer. Having worked for the company since 1983, starting as an apprentice and eventually becoming a team leader, Jones faced difficulties after developing radiation-induced neuropathy, a chronic and painful condition caused by radiotherapy treatment he received for Hodgkin’s lymphoma at age 21. This illness led to severe fatigue, pain, and weakness that made manual work impossible and forced him to take sick leave.

In 2019, Pilkington UK Ltd grew suspicious that Jones was working while on leave and hired a private surveillance firm to observe him. Unbeknownst to Jones, the monitoring extended not only to him but also included his family and a friend’s farm where Jones spent time to aid his recovery. Despite the company’s claims of evidence showing Jones performing physical tasks — like handing over a bag of potatoes and using a hose — Pilkington did not seek any medical opinion regarding his condition. The tribunal later found that these activities were unfairly interpreted as proof he was working, rather than understanding his health limitations.

Following a disciplinary hearing based on the surveillance, Jones was dismissed for gross misconduct. He described the experience as devastating, comparing the loss of his job to “a death in the family” and expressing feelings of betrayal after decades of loyalty to the company. What was most troubling for Jones was the lack of investigation into his medical condition and the company’s readiness to discard his unblemished record on mere suspicion. He said, “I was somebody who showed commitment and loyalty and all that was thrown out the window, and yeah, that was disappointing.”

Jones fought to clear his name with the support of the Unite trade union, engaging in a lengthy legal battle. After winning a first-tier employment tribunal in 2021, Pilkington UK Ltd appealed, but their appeal was dismissed in 2023 with the judge ruling Jones had been unfairly discriminated against because of his disability. Eventually, the company agreed to pay him £329,000 in damages and lost earnings. Reflecting on the outcome, Jones said, “I was sacked through suspicion but vindicated through justice… Money was never the motivation – it was always the sense of justice and making sure it never happened to anyone else.” His legal representatives emphasized the importance of employers properly understanding disabled workers’ conditions rather than relying on assumptions leading to unfair treatment

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More