Why young people in St Ives can't find affordable homes

Why young people in St Ives can't find affordable homes

Ten years after St Ives introduced a ban on new-build properties being sold as second homes, the Cornish town continues to face significant challenges related to housing affordability, fluctuating employment, and the displacement of young locals. The 2016 referendum was a landmark event, conducted in response to census data revealing that about 25% of local homes were used as second residences. This move placed St Ives in the national spotlight as it pioneered restrictions aimed at preserving housing for full-time residents.

The ruling, known as Policy H2, required that newly built homes be occupied by principal residents rather than investors looking for holiday properties. It marked the first instance in the UK where such a rule was mandated for new developments. Similar measures have been enforced in other regions, such as villages in Northumberland and towns like Whitby in Yorkshire, with varying degrees of success. While these rules have helped increase the number of permanent residents in some areas, the seasonal nature of tourism still affects community life, and house prices remain a barrier for many locals.

For young residents like 26-year-old Hannah Roach, whose experience typifies that of many in St Ives, unstable housing is a pressing issue. Having moved multiple times due to increasing rent—rents which at one point rose from £650 to £1,200 monthly—she struggles to secure affordable accommodation. Seasonal work compounds these difficulties, providing limited employment opportunities in the winter months and making it hard to save for a home. Her story highlights the ongoing tension between maintaining a vibrant local community and the economic pressures exerted by the attractiveness of St Ives as a holiday destination.

Despite the intentions behind the legislation, local officials acknowledge that Policy H2 is not a perfect solution. While it has had some impact, loopholes have allowed some purchasers to buy homes under the pretense of full-time residency without fulfilling that commitment. Estate agents and local authorities emphasize the continued need for affordable housing development and sustainable economic opportunities if St Ives is to retain its younger population. The town’s experiences underscore the complexity of balancing tourism-driven economies with the needs of permanent residents in rural and coastal communities

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More