Racism and staffing issues factors in 'failing' maternity care, report finds

Racism and staffing issues factors in 'failing' maternity care, report finds

A recent interim report has highlighted significant shortcomings within maternity services across England, revealing that too many families are encountering problems throughout the entire maternity care process. Leading a government-commissioned review, Baroness Amos identified six major contributing factors to these failures, emphasizing issues such as racism, insufficient staffing, and a lack of accountability.

Baroness Amos has engaged extensively with the public, receiving evidence from over 8,000 individuals and meeting with more than 400 families to inform her findings. The Health Secretary, Wes Streeting, has assured that the government will respond to the final recommendations expected in April. Despite this commitment, several systemic problems continue to undermine the quality and safety of maternity services in England.

The interim report outlines core challenges including understaffed and overstretched services, which have led to delays in admissions and compromised safety, especially when community midwives are called upon to assist in delivery units. Relationships within maternity teams reportedly suffer due to poor dynamics, with incidents of bullying and racism by senior clinicians not always being effectively addressed. Structural inequalities contribute to notably worse outcomes for women from Black, Asian, and marginalized backgrounds, including disabled women, Muslim families, refugees, asylum seekers, and LGBT families. Furthermore, the report criticizes the lack of compassion and transparency following incidents of baby loss or harm, which can cause mothers to wrongly blame themselves and hinder learning from such tragedies. The physical state of some care facilities, described as outdated and dilapidated, also poses risks, with inadequate bereavement spaces in certain trusts compounding the challenges faced by affected families.

Baroness Amos remarked on the persistent failures exposed through her conversations with families and staff, stressing the urgent need for change across maternity and neonatal services. The problems she has uncovered are long-standing and well-documented, with the BBC having spent over a decade gathering accounts from bereaved families impacted by poor care at numerous NHS Trusts throughout England. One such tragic case involves Orlando Davis, who died at just 14 days old after staff failed to detect his mother’s hyponatremia during labour. His family, part of the advocacy group Truth for Our Babies, argue that these issues reflect a wider cultural problem within maternity care where parents’ concerns are often overlooked by healthcare professionals. They have called for a statutory inquiry, criticising the current review as insufficient and expressing doubt that it will lead to meaningful improvements.

Campaigners like Labour MP Michelle Welsh warn that without decisive action, including the speedy formation of a maternity taskforce and the appointment of a maternity commissioner to oversee care standards, the review risks becoming ineffective. Welsh advocates for bold government policies aimed at substantial investment and accountability to secure real progress in maternity services. Although Health Secretary Wes Streeting pledged to convene a taskforce earlier in the year, no such group has yet been announced, highlighting ongoing delays in translating review findings into concrete reforms. The Department for Health and Social Care has stated that the taskforce membership will be revealed soon, with campaigners emphasizing the urgency of establishing this body to drive essential changes

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More