Irish state papers: 'Superiority' concerns over 1996 royal yacht visit

Irish state papers: 'Superiority' concerns over 1996 royal yacht visit

Concerns were raised over the image that would be projected by the royal yacht arriving in Irish ports during a proposed visit in the summer of 1996. British and Irish officials discussed a potential three-day visit to Ireland by the then Prince of Wales, now King Charles III, but the plan was ultimately scrapped due to security worries. Records released by the National Archives of Ireland reveal that the itinerary for the trip had grown more complex than initially intended before it was called off. The Irish prime minister at the time, John Bruton, expressed his view that Ireland was “the last place” where the prince should bring the royal yacht, HMY Britannia.

Bruton cautioned that the arrival of the royal yacht would convey an impression of “opulence,” a sentiment he emphasized in a handwritten response concerning the visit. The HMY Britannia, which served as the British monarchy’s royal yacht from 1954 until 1997, was proposed to arrive in Galway Bay on the morning of 28 June 1996, according to British ambassador Veronica Sutherland. On the first evening, Prince Charles intended to host guests aboard the yacht, which would then sail overnight for a private weekend in Kerry and Cork after the guests disembarked. The visit was described as expanding significantly beyond initial expectations, including a planned stop at Haulbowline harbour in County Cork.

Irish government secretary Frank Murray noted that the visit seemed “far more extensive” than first indicated and stated that the Irish officials felt compelled to follow through with the planned itinerary unless political or security factors dictated otherwise. However, Bruton’s handwritten note to Murray voiced deep reservations, worried that the yacht’s arrival in Galway Bay might reignite old controversies linked to the Treaty ports of the 1930s. He pointed out that the yacht symbolized a sense of superiority and wealth, which was not an appropriate message to convey; he suggested instead that the prince should fly to a regional airport, which could offer more commercial benefits. Bruton also mentioned ongoing criticism in Britain over the yacht’s expense, further underlining why its presence in Ireland was problematic.

By 19 March, Murray confirmed he had communicated Irish government concerns along with security issues to British representatives. He mentioned that a scaled-back version of the visit could be arranged soon, but the plan was eventually abandoned. The cancellation was influenced by Irish apprehensions about the security risks to Charles in the absence of an IRA ceasefire. Documents from the National Archives at Kew, made public in 2020, noted that the use of Britannia during the visit would be unwelcome to some parts of the population, concluding that “the risks now seem to outweigh any benefits.” Separately, in 2003, a request for the British Navy ship HMS Ark Royal to dock in Dublin was rejected by then Taoiseach Bertie Ahern. Senior officials cautioned that the visit would be perceived as a significant policy shift regarding British military presence in Ireland, especially given the vessel’s symbolic status and its role in the Iraq war. Ahern succinctly recorded his decision on the document: “my view is ‘no’.” Today, the HMY Britannia is permanently moored in Leith, Edinburgh, serving as a popular tourist attraction

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More