Covid decision-making in NI was 'chaotic', says inquiry

Covid decision-making in NI was 'chaotic', says inquiry

An official report from the UK Covid-19 Inquiry has revealed significant challenges in the Northern Ireland Executive’s response to the pandemic, highlighting divisions and political conflicts that hampered effective decision-making. The inquiry’s second report criticized how meetings within Stormont’s power-sharing government were deeply fragmented along party lines and frequently affected by leaks, which contributed to what it described as an incoherent overall strategy during the crisis.

Baroness Heather Hallett, chairing the inquiry, characterized the decision-making in Northern Ireland as “chaotic” and heavily influenced by political maneuvering. She pointed out that the contentious relationships among ministers disrupted a unified response. For example, she noted inconsistent application of circuit breaker restrictions, which were extended, then briefly lifted, and later reinstated, resulting in a 25% rise in Covid-19 cases during the lapse. The power-sharing arrangements, intended to foster cooperation, instead impaired the Executive’s ability to act decisively, with ongoing disputes particularly between Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) and Sinn Féin ministers undermining collective action.

The report also pointed to specific incidents that heightened tensions within the governing body. One such instance was when Sinn Féin’s Michelle O’Neill attended the funeral of former IRA leader Bobby Storey, an event described as contributing to strained relations among the five-party executive. Additionally, a four-day executive meeting in November 2020 was described as a low point due to leaks and political tactics, such as the First Minister at the time, Arlene Foster, allegedly using cross-community votes to score political points, further damaging trust and confidentiality.

Furthermore, the inquiry highlighted operational challenges within the Department of Health (DoH), which led the pandemic response. It concluded that the department “largely operated in a silo,” complicating coordinated efforts. The report also raised concerns about how decision-making would have proceeded had the executive still been suspended, given that the pandemic struck soon after Stormont was restored following a three-year breakdown. As part of its recommendations, the report suggests measures to prevent a governance vacuum in Northern Ireland if an emergency arises during any future suspensions.

Northern Ireland’s current First Minister, Michelle O’Neill, responded by welcoming the report as an important step forward in recovering from the pandemic’s impact. She emphasized the unprecedented nature of Covid-19 and expressed hope that the lessons detailed in the report would improve readiness and response for future emergencies, acknowledging the profound loss suffered by many families across society

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More