BBC chair Samir Shah apologises for Panorama Trump edit

BBC chair Samir Shah apologises for Panorama Trump edit

President Donald Trump has issued a threat of legal action against the BBC over concerns with the editing of a speech used in a Panorama documentary. Specifically, his legal team has demanded a full retraction of the documentary by November 14 or face a potential lawsuit amounting to $1 billion. This decision came after a leaked internal BBC memo revealed that the documentary had incorrectly spliced together segments of Trump’s speech to portray him as urging individuals to attack the US Capitol following his electoral loss.

In light of these developments, the BBC’s outgoing news CEO, Deborah Turness, has rejected claims of institutional bias within the corporation. This statement came in response to her resignation alongside director general Tim Davie following mounting pressure over the publication of a critical memo by Michael Prescott, a former external adviser to the broadcaster’s editorial standards committee. The memo highlighted concerns over the BBC’s Gaza coverage, perceived anti-Trump and anti-Israel bias, and one-sided transgender reporting, in addition to the Panorama edit.

While the BBC chair, Samir Shah, acknowledged an “error of judgement” in the documentary’s editing and issued an apology, Trump’s legal team has called for a formal apology and financial compensation to the president. The letter from Trump’s attorney, Alejandro Brito, accused the BBC of defamation under Florida law, citing false and inflammatory statements made about the president. Shah confirmed that the documentary edit had raised concerns within the committee and admitted that more formal action should have been taken in hindsight.

Trump’s speech on January 6, 2021, in which he made remarks about walking to the Capitol, was juxtaposed in the Panorama programme to give the impression of a direct call to action. Despite the segments being over 50 minutes apart originally, the edit created a different narrative. The ongoing debate surrounding the BBC’s journalistic integrity has also attracted political commentary, with statements from Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s office denying allegations of institutional bias at the corporation. The controversy underscores the complex relationship between media outlets and political figures, with legal actions being a common tactic in disputes over editorial content

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More