Gerry Adams: BBC libel case jury have five questions to answer

Gerry Adams: BBC libel case jury have five questions to answer

The verdict in Gerry Adams’ libel case against the BBC hinges on the answers to five critical questions posed to the jury following four weeks of evidence in Dublin. Mr. Adams, the former Sinn Féin president, is suing over a 2016 Spotlight programme and online report that alleged he sanctioned the murder of a British agent, Denis Donaldson. The 12-member jury must determine whether Mr. Adams has been defamed and decide on potential damages ranging from zero to over €300,000, with any award promised by Mr. Adams to go to charitable causes.

The focus of the case is on whether the words used in the BBC’s programme and online story meant that Mr. Adams sanctioned Mr. Donaldson’s murder. Additionally, the jury will assess the BBC’s defense of acting in “good faith” and being “fair and reasonable” in its reporting. Mr. Adams’ lawyers argue for “very substantial” damages of at least €200,000, highlighting his role in the peace process in Northern Ireland. The jury’s decision on damages depends on their interpretation of the words and their rejection of the BBC’s defense.

Denis Donaldson, a pivotal figure in Sinn Féin, was murdered in 2006 after it was revealed he had worked as an informant for the police and MI5 within the party. Despite the Real IRA claiming responsibility for his murder, sources cited by Spotlight linked it to the Provisional IRA. Mr. Donaldson had a complex history, being both interned without trial in the 1970s and later accused of spying for British intelligence. His mysterious death in County Donegal remains shrouded in intrigue.

Gerry Adams, Sinn Féin’s president from 1983 to 2018, played a crucial role in the peace talks that culminated in the Good Friday Agreement, officially bringing an end to the Troubles. Despite enduring periods of internment in the 1970s, Mr. Adams denies ever being a member of the IRA. His reputation and role in the peace process are central to the jury’s deliberations in determining whether he was defamed and, if so, the appropriate level of damages to award

Read the full article from The BBC here: Read More